Courts · 13 Nov 2026, 9:47 am IST

Madras High Court admits challenge to BC and MBC reservation for Christian communities and converts

"There is nothing axiomatic or eternal about one's OBC status," the bench wrote. The State must now show the entries are justified; it has eight weeks to reply.

Slide 1 of 8Slide 2 of 8Slide 3 of 8Slide 4 of 8Slide 5 of 8Slide 6 of 8Slide 7 of 8Slide 8 of 8

Verified factOn 12 Nov 2026 the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court (Justices G.R. Swaminathan and M.D. Sumathi) admitted WP(MD) No. 32363 of 2026, which asks the court to strike down entries in Schedule I of the Tamil Nadu Government Servants (Conditions of Service) Act, 2016 that give Backward Class (Part A) or Most Backward Class (Part C) status to Christian communities and converts to Christianity (order, p.2 and paras 4, 13).

Verified factThe bench wrote: "There is nothing axiomatic or eternal about one's OBC status." When a challenge is mounted, "the Government is obliged to demonstrate to the Court's satisfaction" that inclusion or retention is warranted (para 1). It found a prima facie case "that warrants deep constitutional scrutiny" (para 12).

AllegationThe petitioner, from the Kallar community (a notified Backward Class) and a candidate in the TNPSC Group IV recruitment, contends the communities and converts were included without "any empirical test of social and educational backwardness as mandated by Article 16(4)" (para 3). He says the 1985 Ambashankar Commission found "Christian (Converts from B.C.)" not eligible, and that the entries were added by Government Orders in 1983 and 1986 (paras 5-6).

AllegationHe points to what he calls an anomaly: a Scheduled Caste person who converts to Christianity is listed as Backward Class, while converts from certain Most Backward Classes (Meenavar, Parvatharajakulam, Mukkuvar) keep Most Backward Class status (para 10). His counsel also asserted that a Brahmin who joins the CSI can claim OBC status; the court said, "If this assertion is true, then a serious re-think is certainly called for" (para 2).

Official recordThe State's published list (BC, MBC & Minorities Welfare Department) lists converts to Christianity from Scheduled Castes as BC "irrespective of the generation of conversion" (entry 18); C.S.I. (formerly S.I.U.C.) as BC "in Kanniyakumari District and Shencottah Taluk of Tirunelveli District" (entry 19); converts from other Hindu BC, MBC and denotified communities as BC (entry 142); and Paravar, Meenavar and Mukkuvar "including converts to Christianity" as MBC (entries 170-172).

Official recordOn 15 Oct 2026 the Supreme Court (SLP(C) No. 25507 of 2026, 2026 INSC 1129) upheld the Madras High Court's quashing of a Tamil Nadu order on BC Muslim certificates for converts to Islam. It held that no Article 16(4) benefit "the enjoyment of which is predicated upon a particular Hindu social order, can be claimed or extended merely on the basis of such antecedent membership after the person has converted to Islam, Christianity or any other non-Hindu social order" (para 61(e)). The petitioner relies on this ruling (para 8).

Official recordThe State, represented by the Special Government Pleader, has not yet replied; the order records no submissions on its behalf. Notice is returnable in eight weeks. The TNPSC was added as a respondent, and because recruitment is ongoing the petitioner may file an interim application (paras 13-14).

UnverifiedNot yet known: the State's defence and any data it holds on the backwardness of the listed communities; whether interim relief will be sought for the Group IV recruitment.

The proof.

Every quotation is verbatim from the court's order or the Supreme Court judgment, with paragraph numbers, and was machine-checked against the source text; the highlighted page images are rendered from the order PDF.

Published 13 Nov 2026, 9:47 am IST · Corrections: none · How to read our labels