Politics · 13 Nov 2026, 9:47 am IST

Sonia Gandhi's memoir against the record: 1984, Godhra and Kharge

The memoir links the 1984 Army delay to the Army Chief; the commission record puts the delay in calling the Army on Delhi's administration. It says four coaches burned at Godhra; the record names one, S-6.

Slide 1 of 9Slide 2 of 9Slide 3 of 9Slide 4 of 9Slide 5 of 9Slide 6 of 9Slide 7 of 9Slide 8 of 9Slide 9 of 9

ReportedSonia Gandhi's memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, was released by HarperCollins India on 10 Nov 2026. We checked three of its most consequential historical claims against the primary record. The memoir's wording below is as quoted in published extracts; we have not yet checked it against a copy of the book.

Allegation1984. The memoir (ch. 17, p.265, as quoted) says the Chief of Army Staff, Gen. A.S. Vaidya, "had received his orders the same night as the assassination, we heard later that he decided not to mobilise the nearest units because they were manned by Sikh soldiers", and that he ordered units from Dehradun instead.

Official recordThe Justice Nanavati Commission report (Vol. I, 9 Feb 2005, p.2) records that the earlier Misra Commission found "delay on the part of Delhi Administration i.e. the Lt.Governor and the Commissioner of Police in calling the Army, though about 5,000 Army men were available by mid night of October 31." The Nanavati Commission "also agrees with the findings recorded by Justice Mishra Commission as regards the delay in calling the army" (p.183). The same paragraph on p.2 records that Misra ruled out participation by the Congress(I) Party or its leaders, while finding that some Congress members took part on their own.

AllegationThe Delhi Area commander, Maj. Gen. J.S. Jamwal, told the Nanavati Commission that at about 11 a.m. on 1 Nov 1984 the Army Chief told him to be ready "if any request is received for help from civil authorities"; that he directed troops to Central and South Delhi at 2.02 p.m. that day; and that "the army was deployed late in the evening of 2-11-84" and "became effective from 3-11-84 in some areas" (pp.136–137).

AllegationDr P.C. Alexander told the Commission that Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi decided to call in the Army at 1.30 p.m. on 1 Nov, and that the Army Chief "was already alerted" (p.174). The then Lt Governor, P.G. Gavai, said he told the Police Commissioner at 7.30 a.m. on 1 Nov that the Army would have to be called; he "denied that he had failed to anticipate violence and delayed calling the Army" and said the Misra report misquoted him (pp.171–173).

UnverifiedThe Nanavati report does not address whether Sikh-manned units were held back, the reason the memoir gives. We have not obtained the Misra Commission report itself.

CommentaryH.S. Phoolka, senior advocate for 1984 victims and a BJP member, called the memoir's account "absolutely false" (as reported, 12 Nov).

FalseGodhra. The memoir (as quoted) says "four coaches of the Sabarmati Express were set on fire". The record names one coach: the Nanavati-Mehta Commission (Part I, 18 Sep 2008, para 227) concluded that "burning of coach S/6 was a pre-planned act"; the Gujarat High Court's 2017 judgment deals with the fire in coach S-6.

CommentaryThe memoir says "the cause of the fire remains disputed". This is the author's view.

Verified factThe Gujarat High Court (Criminal Confirmation Case No. 1 of 2011 and connected appeals, judgment of 9 Oct 2017) held that the evidence established the prosecution's case under IPC sections 302, 120B and 149, murder, conspiracy and unlawful assembly (p.875). It upheld the convictions of 31 people: 20 life sentences upheld, and 11 death sentences commuted to life imprisonment (pp.985–986).

ReportedAppeals against the High Court judgment are pending in the Supreme Court, which began the final hearing in May 2025.

UnverifiedKharge. The memoir is quoted as saying that when Mallikarjun Kharge was seven, "his home and family had been set on fire in caste riots, leaving him and his father". This wording has been quoted by one outlet and matches a photo of the page posted on X; we have not checked it against the book.

ReportedKharge's own account, in a video posted on his X account on 13 Jun 2026: Razakars, the Nizam of Hyderabad's militia, set fire to his home; "My mother was killed ... My brother died, my sister died and my uncle passed away too." In Nov 2024 his son Priyank Kharge said the family never held any community responsible.

UnverifiedResponse from Sonia Gandhi, the Congress or HarperCollins India: none found at the time of writing.

The proof.

Every quotation from the commission reports and the High Court judgment is verbatim, with page numbers, and was machine-checked against the PDFs; the highlighted page images are rendered from the original PDFs. Memoir wording is as published in extracts and is labelled accordingly.

Published 13 Nov 2026, 9:47 am IST · Corrections: none · How to read our labels