Courts · 15 Nov 2026, 7:22 am IST

Supreme Court: Punjab and Haryana to supply Himachal 11,973 MU of power owed for 1966–2011, over 20 years

Thirty years after Himachal Pradesh filed its suit, the court has settled how the state's 7.19% share of Bhakra-Nangal and Beas power, decreed in 2011, is to be paid for the years it was not supplied: in energy, not cash, with Himachal's share of the projects' capital cost set off.

Slide 1 of 8Slide 2 of 8Slide 3 of 8Slide 4 of 8Slide 5 of 8Slide 6 of 8Slide 7 of 8Slide 8 of 8

Verified factOn 6 November 2026 the Supreme Court disposed of the suit filed by Himachal Pradesh in 1996 under Article 131 of the Constitution against the Union of India, Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Chandigarh (State of Himachal Pradesh v. Union of India & Ors., Original Suit No. 2 of 1996, 2026 INSC 1200). The bench was Chief Justice Surya Kant, who wrote the judgment, and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana. The court described the exercise as "in the nature of execution proceedings" of its 2011 decree, not a reopening of it (para 30).

Verified factThe 2011 decree. By its judgment of 27.09.2011, the court held Himachal entitled to 7.19% of the power attributable to composite Punjab, corresponding to 6.095% of the total power of the Bhakra-Nangal Project from 01.11.1966, 5.752% of Beas Unit I and 2.984% of Beas Unit II from the dates each began production (para 5.23). The 7.19% figure was the share of composite Punjab's population transferred to Himachal in the 1966 reorganisation (para 5.12). The court rejected Himachal's separate claim to 12% free power (para 5.22). The Union Power Ministry revised allocations from 01.11.2011 (para 5.27); the dispute since then has been over the energy not supplied before that date.

Official recordThe arrears. In an affidavit of 05.07.2013, the Union of India computed Himachal's unpaid entitlement for 01.11.1966 to October 2011 at 8,523 million units (MU) from Bhakra-Nangal, 3,145 MU from Beas Unit I and 1,398 MU from Beas Unit II: 13,066 MU in all. Himachal accepted this; Punjab and Haryana disputed it (para 5.28).

Verified factThe directions (para 41). The arrears are taken at 13,066 MU. Himachal's liability for its 7.19% share of the projects' capital cost, "the unreimbursed share of loan servicing undertaken by Punjab and Haryana since 1966–67", is assessed at ₹420.77 crore (₹249.23 crore attributable to Punjab, ₹171.55 crore to Haryana). That liability is set off against the arrears at ₹3.85 a unit, about 1,093 MU. The balance, about 11,973 MU, is to be supplied by Punjab and Haryana at about 598 MU a year over 20 lean seasons (October to March), in the ratio 58:42 for Bhakra-Nangal and 60:40 for the Beas projects. Himachal pays the charges fixed by the Bhakra Beas Management Board (BBMB) for the year each tranche is received. The settlement is "cashless": no direct payment between the states.

AllegationThe Union's case (paras 9–11, 20–22): the Attorney General proposed supplying the 13,066 MU in kind over 15 years at 871 MU a year, with the capital-cost liability, reconstructed from CAG loan data at about ₹420.77 crore up to 2025–26, set off at ₹3.85 a unit, leaving about 11,973 MU at about 798 MU a year.

AllegationHimachal's case (paras 6–8, 23): it accepted the 13,066 MU figure but argued for valuing it at the BTPS rate, which gave a claim of ₹4,249.45 crore, and also sought ₹1,745 crore for power bought on the open market between 1989 and 2011. It agreed to the Union's framework in principle on 30.07.2026 and 20.08.2026.

AllegationPunjab's case (paras 12–15, 24–26): Himachal had separately received 1.2 lakh units a day at a concessional rate, about 1,972 MU, which would cut the arrears to 11,094 MU; the capital-cost set-off should be valued at the current O&M rate of 79 paise, which would leave 5,768 MU due; and the energy should be spread over 30 years. Earlier, Punjab had put Himachal's capital-cost liability, with interest, at ₹6,368.29 crore as on 31.03.2026.

AllegationHaryana's case (paras 16–19, 23): it argued that the 58:42 split overstated its share and put its own liability at 3,809.77 MU, and questioned the BBMB data as "neither authenticated nor audited". It later agreed to the Union's framework in principle.

Verified factThe court's answer (paras 32–38, 43). Punjab's contentions were "vague and superficial" and "an attempt to relitigate issues already settled"; the 1.2 lakh units a day had "already been considered and accounted for" in the capital-cost liability; converting the liability at today's O&M rate would "inflate the liability", since the arrears relate to an earlier period. The court nevertheless raised the period from 15 to 20 years "with a view to easing the burden on the Defendant States". It said its directions "are binding and are required to be acted upon without reservation".

CommentaryChief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu (INC), on 7 November, as reported by The Tribune: "Our single-engine government delivered what the double-engine government couldn't." He said the state agreed to sign the Kishau Dam MoU only after Haryana agreed to file an affidavit in the Supreme Court stating it had no objection to the settlement of the state's dues, and that it could earn "nearly Rs 10,000 crore" if it sold the power at Rs 10 a unit. These are his statements; we have not seen the affidavit or the correspondence he described, and the revenue figure is his estimate.

CommentaryLeader of the Opposition Jai Ram Thakur (BJP), at a press conference in Shimla on 7 November, as reported by The Tribune, said the decision reflected three decades of litigation, successive state governments and the Centre's contribution, and that the 2011 judgment came when Prem Kumar Dhumal (BJP) was Chief Minister: "The present Congress government cannot erase this history merely because the final judgment has been delivered during its tenure." He asked whether the government would now provide the 300 units of free electricity it had promised.

Verified factPunjab (AAP government) and Haryana (BJP government): we found no public statement from either government on the judgment as of 15 November 2026. Their positions in court are summarised above from the judgment.

Verified factWhat to watch. The judgment does not set a date for the first lean-season supply, and does not say how the BBMB will schedule it. The annual figures are approximate: 11,973 MU over 20 seasons is 598.65 MU a year, which the court gives as "approximately 598". The judgment's own two components of the capital-cost liability, ₹249.23 crore and ₹171.55 crore, add to ₹420.78 crore, ₹0.01 crore more than the total it states.

The proof.

Every figure is taken from the Supreme Court's judgment of 6 November 2026, with paragraph and page, and recomputed: 8,523 + 3,145 + 1,398 = 13,066 MU; ₹420.77 crore ÷ ₹3.85 = 1,092.9 MU; 13,066 − 1,093 = 11,973 MU; Punjab's figure, 11,094 MU less ₹420.77 crore ÷ ₹0.79, gives 5,768 MU. Every quotation was machine-checked against the judgment text and the reports cited. The highlighted page images are rendered from the judgment PDF.

Published 15 Nov 2026, 7:22 am IST · Corrections: none · How to read our labels