Courts · 13 Nov 2026, 10:30 pm IST

Allahabad High Court sees "total lethargy and inaction" in completing UP police investigations; asks the Home Department for a plan

In a Sultanpur murder case, further investigation ordered in February is still open. The court wants the Additional Chief Secretary (Home) to say how investigations can be time-bound. NCRB data puts UP's year-end pendency below the national figure.

Slide 1 of 8Slide 2 of 8Slide 3 of 8Slide 4 of 8Slide 5 of 8Slide 6 of 8Slide 7 of 8Slide 8 of 8

Verified factThe Allahabad High Court (Lucknow Bench), in an order of 3 November 2026 by Justices Abdul Moin and Pramod Kumar Srivastava, said: "it is, thus, apparent that there is total lethargy and inaction on the part of the Investigating Officers in completing the investigation subsequent to lodging of FIRs. The problem is not only confined to one district rather it appears to be prevailing throughout the State of U.P. However, this may not be taken as if we have given final opinion with regard to the malady." (Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 10849 of 2026, para 24).

Official recordThe case: FIR No. 309 of 24 November 2024 at Jaisinghpur police station, Sultanpur district, includes Section 103 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (murder) and provisions of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. A chargesheet was filed on 21 April 2025 (order, paras 3–5 and 8).

Verified factOn 21 February 2026 the Additional Civil Judge (Junior Division)/Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Sultanpur, found the investigation prima facie "unbelievable and unnatural" and directed further investigation by a Circle Officer. The High Court noted that "a period of more than eight months have elapsed and the authorities have failed to conclude the investigation" (paras 5, 9, 10).

AllegationThe State's response in court: the Additional Government Advocate, on instructions from the investigating sub-inspector dated 31 October 2026, said the matter is being further investigated and "as of date the matter is still under investigation" (para 7).

AllegationThe complainant asks the court to move the investigation from the local police to the CB-CID or a court-monitored SIT. The court has not yet ruled on this; no notice has been issued to the private respondents at this stage (paras 2–4).

Verified factThe law, as quoted by the court: Section 193(1) of the BNSS says "Every investigation under this Chapter shall be completed without unnecessary delay." Only investigations into specified sexual offences and POCSO offences have a fixed two-month limit. The police must also tell the informant or victim of the progress of the investigation within 90 days (paras 13–19); Rule 19 of the UP rules provides for this by SMS, email or post (para 20).

Verified factThe court said it is "high time that the higher authorities should step in and frame modalities pertaining to the time frame" for completing investigations, "including punitive action to be taken against the Investigating Officers who do not complete the investigation within a specified time" (para 25).

Verified factDirections: the Additional Chief Secretary (Home) is to file a personal affidavit within three weeks on fixing a time frame for completing investigations, "if possible, and if not, as to how this malady of investigation being kept hanging fire for years on end is to be remedied", and on the number of cases in which progress information was sent to complainants or victims, for FIRs lodged in Sultanpur district. The case is listed on 8 December 2026; if the affidavit is not filed, the ACS (Home) is to appear in person with the records (paras 26–30).

Official recordThe full picture (NCRB, Crime in India 2024, Vol. III, Table 17A.2): in 2024 UP police had 4,87,493 IPC/BNS cases for investigation (56,941 pending from 2023 plus 4,30,552 registered). They disposed of 4,42,717, including 3,39,659 chargesheets, a charge-sheeting rate of 76.7% (India: 72.1%). 44,776 cases were pending investigation at the end of 2024, a pendency of 9.2% (India: 31.2%).

Verified factBy our recomputation, cases pending investigation in UP fell 21.4% during 2024, from 56,941 to 44,776. Some reports quote 75.6% as India's charge-sheeting rate; that is the states-only total in the table. The all-India figure, including Union Territories, is 72.1%.

CommentaryOur note on what the data does not show: the NCRB pendency figure counts cases still open at the end of the year. It does not measure how long each investigation took, the quality of chargesheets, or delays after a court orders further investigation, which is what this case is about. NCRB itself cautions that states should not be compared purely on crime figures. 2024 is the latest year published.

Official recordUttar Pradesh is governed by the BJP. We found no public statement from the UP government or the Home Department on this order beyond its submission in court.

The proof.

Every quotation is copied from the signed order and checked by script; every NCRB number is read from Table 17A.2 and recomputed from its columns (totals, disposals, rates).

Published 13 Nov 2026, 10:30 pm IST · Corrections: none · How to read our labels