Palathayi case: Supreme Court issues notice on Kerala's challenge to the suspension of a former BJP leader's life sentence
Padmarajan @ Pappan Mash was sentenced in November 2025 to life imprisonment for the remainder of his natural life for raping a 10-year-old girl. The Kerala High Court suspended the sentence in August 2026, finding prima facie an arguable case. The State of Kerala has asked the Supreme Court to set that aside.








ReportedOn 17 November 2026, a Supreme Court bench of Justices M.M. Sundresh and Prasanna B. Varale issued notice on the State of Kerala's petition challenging the Kerala High Court's order suspending the sentence of Padmarajan @ Pappan Mash, a former BJP leader, in the Palathayi child rape case (State of Kerala v. Padmarajan @ Pappan Mash and Anr.; SLP (Crl) No. 18744/2026 as listed by LiveLaw). Notice means the court has sought his response; it has not stayed or set aside the High Court's order. We have not yet seen the Supreme Court's order, and the next date of hearing has not been reported.
Official recordThe conviction, as recorded by the High Court: the Fast Track Special Court, Thalassery (S.C. No. 472 of 2021), in its judgment dated 14 November 2025, found him guilty under sections 376(2)(f), 376AB and 354B of the Indian Penal Code and sections 5(f), (l) and (m) read with section 6 of the POCSO Act. It sentenced him to imprisonment for life for the remainder of his natural life and a fine of ₹1 lakh under section 376AB IPC, and to 20 years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹50,000 on each of the counts under sections 5(f) and 5(l) of the POCSO Act (High Court order, paras 2–3). The girl was 10 years and 6 months old; he was her teacher. The case was registered on 17 March 2020 on her statement. At trial, 40 prosecution witnesses and three defence witnesses were examined (paras 3–4).
Verified factThe suspension: on 20 August 2026, a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court (Justices Raja Vijayaraghavan V. and K.V. Jayakumar; order by Justice Jayakumar) allowed his application under section 430(1) of the BNSS in his pending appeal, Crl.A No. 2327 of 2025, and released him on bail. The court said that on a preliminary analysis it found, prima facie, that the child had given an "inconsistent, embellished, improved and fanciful version" (para 18); noted that one doctor had found no evidence of sexual abuse while another had recorded findings and said a tear could have had another cause (para 19); and noted that three investigating agencies had reached different conclusions (para 20). It held that he had "made out an arguable case" and that there was "some infirmity in the order of conviction that renders the order of conviction prima facie erroneous", while saying it was "premature to enter into a conclusive finding" on his claim of innocence (para 22).
Verified factThe bail conditions: a bond of ₹1 lakh with two sureties; he "shall not enter the Revenue District in which the survivor resides"; he must not contact the survivor, her friends or relatives; he must not comment on the case on social media or give interviews; and he may not leave the country without the court's permission (para 23).
AllegationHis case, as recorded by the High Court: his counsel argued that the child's evidence was contradictory, that the medical evidence did not support the prosecution, and that he was "falsely implicated in this case due to political animosity and vengeance" because, as a "BJP sympathiser", he had "published a Facebook post supporting the Citizenship Amendment Bill" (paras 6.1–6.5).
AllegationThe prosecution's case in the High Court: the Special Public Prosecutor opposed the application, said the trial court had evaluated the child's evidence properly and that a doctor's evidence corroborated her, and argued, relying on the Supreme Court's Preet Pal Singh ruling, that unless the trial court's findings are "palpably perverse" the sentence should not be suspended in grave sexual offences against children (paras 7–8). Counsel for the survivor's mother said the trial court had rightly found him guilty and that after conviction "the presumption of innocence no longer exists" (paras 9–10).
ReportedThe State of Kerala's petition in the Supreme Court seeks to set aside the suspension, according to reports. Its detailed grounds have not been reported, and we have not seen the petition.
CommentaryA suspension of sentence is not an acquittal: the conviction stands while his appeal against it is pending in the High Court. We do not publish anything that could identify the survivor, as the POCSO Act (section 23) requires.
The proof.
Every date, section, sentence and quote is checked against the High Court's 16-page order of 20 August 2026; check.py passes. The Supreme Court's notice of 17 November is labelled as reported (five outlets agree on the bench and the notice) until its order is available. The convict's photo is a file photo published by Onmanorama; its date is not known.